Kaif Slams Siraj Omission: Even Tendulkar Would Face the Axe

Should a bowler’s worth be judged solely on two or three recent outings, or must past pedigree, experience, and sustained service to the national side carry genuine weight? That question has moved to the centre of Indian cricket’s selection debate following the controversial omission of fast bowler Mohammed Siraj from the playing eleven for the opening Test against New Zealand.

For two days, commentators and supporters alike have questioned the rationale behind leaving out one of India’s most established seamers. Former Indian batter Mohammad Kaif has now entered the fray with a sharp critique of the current team management, accusing the decision-makers of disregarding seniority and proven overseas credentials in favour of short-termism.

Siraj, who emerged as India’s standout bowler during the demanding tour of England in 2025, found himself watching from the sidelines as the selectors opted for a seam attack comprising Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna, and Anshul Kamboj. For a bowler who has shouldered heavy workloads across continents over the past several years, the exclusion came as a stark surprise.

Speaking on his YouTube channel, Kaif argued that the episode reflects a broader cultural shift within the Indian dressing room, where established reputations offer little insulation against brief dips in form.

“Under this management, such incidents have become entirely routine,” Kaif said. “Play poorly in just two or three matches, and your place immediately comes under scrutiny. Even if Sachin Tendulkar were in this side and endured two or three lean games, questions would be raised about him too. Perhaps even he would have been dropped.”

Kaif contended that a pattern has emerged in how seasoned campaigners are treated, suggesting that past achievements are routinely overlooked when squad spots are contested. “This management has never placed real value on seniority,” he remarked. “Look at Kuldeep Yadav, Ravichandran Ashwin, Rohit Sharma, Virat Kohli, Suryakumar Yadav—even Mohammed Shami was never brought back. They have never shown due respect to senior players. Their mindset is simple: you may be a senior figure, but what have you delivered right now? The exact same fate has befallen Siraj.”

Despite his strong defence of the Hyderabad-born pacer, Kaif offered a balanced assessment by acknowledging Siraj’s subdued returns during India’s Test tour of Sri Lanka in August, where he managed four wickets across two matches. “I accept that he did not perform at his best in Sri Lanka, and his pace had dropped off slightly,” Kaif noted. “In Asian conditions, Ravichandran Ashwin and Ravindra Jadeja have traditionally been India’s primary wicket-takers, while in Colombo, Jadeja and Manav Suthar bowled the bulk of the overs.”

Kaif is far from alone in his bewilderment. Batting legend Sunil Gavaskar also expressed his astonishment while speaking to the host broadcasters, admitting that while subtle warning signs had appeared earlier on the tour, the final decision remained difficult to comprehend.

“It is not merely surprising; it is genuinely astonishing,” Gavaskar observed. “There were hints, of course. He was included in the One-Day International squad yet featured only in the final match. At the time, I assumed they were giving him game time purely as preparation for the opening Test.”

Gavaskar maintained that Siraj’s track record warranted far greater backing, particularly in conditions that typically reward seam movement. “Seeing him left out of the playing eleven caught me completely off guard,” he added. “I do not believe he has ever let India down. Nothing has happened with his bowling that justifies dropping him.”

As the series progresses, the scrutiny on India’s selection policy is unlikely to fade. With a youthful seam attack entrusted to deliver in New Zealand, the management’s bold call to sideline a proven match-winner will inevitably be judged against results on the field.

Tags :

Mursaline Mahmud Taisin | Sub-Editor । khaborwala.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you human? Please solve:Captcha


Recent News

Editor & Publisher: A. B. M. Zakirul Haque Titon

Khaborwala is a trusted online news portal delivering the latest news and updates from Bangladesh and around the world. Covering politics, national and local news, education, sports, business, entertainment, and international affairs, Khaborwala provides readers with reliable, timely, and informative news.

© 2026 Khaborwala. All Rights Reserved